Thoreau Thursdays (26): Uncommon Schools to Soar Beyond Provincialsim

October 13, 2011

“It is time that we had uncommon schools, that we did not leave off our education when we begin to be men and women.  It is time that villages were universities, and their elder inhabitants the fellows of universities, with leisure . . . to pursue liberal studies the rest of their lives. . . .Why should our life be in any respect provincial?”
      — Henry David Thoreau, Walden

Reading the classics in today's world

Downloadable formats now make reading more accessible than ever.

Thoreau makes a case for a liberal arts education, reading the classics, and lifelong learning.  He felt it was not enough to focus solely on things that farmers and traders value, but that money could be spent on bringing scholars and lecturers and culture to the people.

In today’s world, wired to the Internet, we have ready access to the best of the world’s literature, music, and the arts.  The selection is almost unlimited; we are limited only by our choices.  But how poorly we often choose.  We have so much more leisure time than our great-grandparents, and yet so often our lives feel culturally impoverished.  In today’s world, we have no excuse for starvation for excellence except our own laziness.

One of my all-time favorite writers, Carol Bly, investigates this fall into intellectual poverty in an essay, “A Gentle Education for Us All” from her book,  Letters from the Country.  She observes that, “The granddaughters of the women who piled turkey and dressing and four pies and jars of homemade gooseberry preserves onto the church sawhorse tables now come to the county fair with pie-mix pies and to church suppers with very third-rate hot dishes based on fake Chinese noodles and artificially flavored gelatin salads.  . . . All this second-rate behavior is no elegant moral breakdown in my opinion, but rather the result of everyone being told ever since the end of World War II that your image in others’ eyes, as well as your own, had to do mainly with your vocation and your acquired property.”  Schools and educators postitioned arts, music, and literature as impractical in a world where everything of value was thought of in terms of a job.

Bly recognizes that technical competence is good, and does indeed have value, for eight hours of one’s life.  But what of the other 16 hours of the day?  Bly advocates for educating the whole person by means of a return to a liberal arts education because the best literature and art and music illuminates the circumstances of our own lives.  Liberal arts educates for happiness.

I have often thought that a public school education is wasted on youth;  I would appreciate it so much more at my age.  When I was 30 years old, I did break from my working life to go back to college for a graduate degree.  These days, with another decade of working life ahead of me, I am challenged to keep growing and learning on my own.  Our wonderful libraries and the internet do make lifelong learning easier.  But what’s missing from my life is a classroom of kindred seekers and a gifted teacher who can inspire creative thinking on topics of interest or open windows to new interests outside my immediate sphere. I know these kinds of opportunities are out there, especially for retired people.  It will be my job to find them.

6 Responses to “Thoreau Thursdays (26): Uncommon Schools to Soar Beyond Provincialsim”

  1. Donna Says:

    Rosemary this is such a thought provoking post especially for me since I am an educator. At this point close to retirement and working in ed administration. I think you have hit upon the crux of what is bothering me. I do not use e-readers. I like books. I love to read. But TV has been a problem for many since the baby boomers when it enthralled us and took over our lives. Now it is worse if that is possible. Add to that computers and other gadgets and we are never engaged in much deep, real learning. I will have to get Carol’s book…I finally fell off the job/work wagon a year ago and am much happier although I am still finding my way in my new life without my job taking over my life.

  2. Shirley Says:


  3. In South Africa, and I’m sure in many other countries, we have U3A. University of the Third Age. Not yet for me, but I hope later to join in.

    Your picture today makes me nostalgic for the university libraries I worked in.

    • Rosemary Says:

      Your U3A sounds wonderful. The US had Elderhostel among other programs. I still have to work for another 10 years, so it’s too early for me to enroll in some of the offerings now.

  4. I, too, am seeking seekers. Let’s talk!

Leave a Reply to Shirley Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: